At home with the McMuffins   
Blog   About   Archives   Links of love   Obsessions 
 
 
 
     
   

« a little problem...solved | Main | bloody spammers »


cidade de deus

I've been thinking about City of God, or rather I have been thinking about that fact that the film was co-directed by Kátia Lund. The other director, Fernando Meirelles has been praised by the media and has gone on to make a big budget hollywood thriller, The Constant Gardener. The odd thing about this partnership is that the awards industry both in the US and UK refused to recognise that the film was co-directed. Fernando Meirelles was nominated for an Oscar and a BAFTA award for City of God, while Kátia Lund was ignored. I remember hearing her being interviewed on BBC Radio 4's Woman's Hour when the Oscar nomination was announced. She tried to put on a brave face, claiming that even though she had not been nominated, both she and Meirelles knew that they had made the film together, and any award would still be an award for her. I don't have any point to make, really. I just wanted to acknowledge Kátia Lund's contribution. I guess, I have puzzled over this strange incident for a couple of years. I don't doubt that there is a casual sexism involved, but what I don't understand is that once the mistake had been pointed out, why was it not corrected?

mr mcmuffin on 9 Nov 2005 @ 11:02 AM ✲ Permalink

Comments

Funnily enough, Fernando comments on that in this month's Empire. It's not online though. :(

According to him, although Kátia did want to be co-director, he kept the reigns to himself. But he gave her the credit of co-director to acknowledge her huge contribution to the film.

He implies that she got a bit carried away but stresses that they're still friends. Make of that what you will. ^_^

And, um, "Hollywood thriller"? The Constant Gardener is a British independent film, as evidenced by its multitude of awards at the British Independent Film Awards. :P

Posted by: Pacian | 17 Nov 2005 23:37:04

Thanks for that, Pacian-we'll go out and buy a copy just for the interview.

Posted by: mrs mcmuffin | 19 Nov 2005 10:00:27

Post a comment






 
     
 
© 2004 Mr and Mrs McMuffin Email RSS TypePad